Beyond the Algorithm: Discernment in the Digital Age of Spirituality
Spirituality has never been more clickable. Midnight TikTok rituals, bite-sized meditation apps, Instagram reels that remix timeless wisdom with modern hustle, this buffet is endless and tailored for our tastes.
This democratization is, in many ways, a gift. More of us are stepping away from inherited forms of religion to craft personal paths that actually fit our lives. We’re “re-enchanting” the world on our own terms.
And yet, the same forces that make spiritual life accessible also make it shallow; what’s meaningful becomes marketable; what’s complex becomes clickable. As a psychodynamic therapist who works at the intersections of somatic practice, mindfulness, thought, and non-ordinary states of consciousness, I want to name both the beauty and the trap of our moment. The beauty is you have permission to explore. The trap is self-deception dressed in aesthetically pleasing, algorithm-approved clothing.
Healing is relational, not transactional.
That single sentence is my North Star for navigating this terrain.
To unbundle this all is tricky, especially because there is a shadow side to all of this. We live in a pluralistic moment sometimes labeled “New Age” or “holistic spirituality,” where elements from Eastern religions, Western esotericism, and Indigenous practices are woven into personal mosaics.
This unbundling offers genuine freedom: one is no longer bound by geography or gatekeepers. We can learn breathwork in Berlin, Tibetan chants on YouTube, and prayer forms from contemplative Christianity on a podcast during your morning run.
But pluralism without depth can become spiritual sampling, kind of like speed-dating wisdom traditions. Without context, mentorship, or community, we risk collecting experiences instead of cultivating practice.
The difference is subtle but decisive: experiences happen to us; practices grow us.
This ‘quick fix’ approach is tempting, and I will go on record to say it’s a myth. Digital culture trains us to expect immediacy: same-day delivery, instant streaming, one-click checkout. It’s natural to import those expectations into our spiritual lives: Manifest your soul mate in 21 days. Trauma cleared in one ceremony. Shadow work—done by Friday!
There’s nothing wrong with wanting relief because this want is a human need. Pain seeks a way out. But every wisdom lineage I trust says growth is earned over time such as through commitment, humility, relationship, and repair.
Psychodynamically, the quick-fix impulse often plays as a spiritual bypass: we leap over grief, rage, shame, and attachment wounds, and call the jump “transcendence.” It feels good until the unmetabolized material returns which it will in some way and often with a sharper edge.
Non-ordinary states, including those catalyzed by breathwork, meditation, or certain ceremonial contexts, do open doors. But the house you enter still needs maintenance. Insight is the invitation; integration is the transformation.
WALLACE MURRAY
Psychotherapy | Coaching | Facilitation | Educator | Urban Shamanism | Psychedelic Assisted Therapy