Why It Is So Hard to Make Decisions

There’s a quiet ache that many of us carry, such as the struggle of not knowing which way to turn. We sit with decisions, big and small, and feel the weight of them pressing into our chest. Do I take this job or that one? Do I stay in this relationship or step away? Do I speak my truth, or do I swallow it for the sake of peace?

And often, instead of clarity, we find ourselves circling. Analyzing every angle, looping back to the same starting place, frozen in a fog of “what ifs.” If you’ve ever found yourself here, like paralyzed or repeating old patterns, know that you’re not alone. This is part of being human. But it’s also a place where life invites us into deeper honesty with ourselves.

The Three Centers of Knowing

When I sit with clients, I often invite them to notice how decision-making is not just a mental exercise. We carry three primary centers of knowing:

  • The Mind can analyze, weigh options, and discern. But on its own, it can tie us up in endless pros and cons.
  • The Heart can dream and feel what’s possible. Yet without courage, those longings remain visions on a shelf.
  • The Gut can push for instinctive action. But without the grounding of mind and heart, it can feel reckless or untrustworthy.

When these three centers are disconnected, decisions become tangled. One part of us surges ahead, while another hesitates, and yet another pulls in the opposite direction. No wonder we feel stuck.

Why Life Makes It Hard

It would be simple if decisions were just about gathering enough information. But our lives are full of influences that pull us away from authenticity:

  • Family Expectations: Many of us were raised to please others. We learned early that belonging sometimes meant betraying our true desires.
  • Cultural Narratives: Our society rewards achievement, productivity, and appearances. Saying “no” to the path of success—at least as it’s defined by others—can feel like failure.
  • Fear of Disappointment: We worry about letting people down. We hesitate to choose because we don’t want to hurt, offend, or upset.
  • Old Wounds: Trauma and past experiences whisper warnings: “Don’t risk it. Don’t trust yourself. Don’t try again.”

Each of these influences can feel louder than our own inner voice. Over time, we stop asking ourselves what we truly want, and instead ask, What will keep me safe? What will make others happy? What will prevent loss?

That is how life, without us even noticing, erodes authenticity. Our decisions become about survival and adaptation, not about alignment.

The Myth of the “Perfect” Decision

Another reason decision-making is so hard is that we secretly believe there’s a perfect answer—one choice that will guarantee happiness, certainty, or security. We treat decisions like math equations, searching for a solution that leaves no remainder.

But life doesn’t work that way. Every decision comes with trade-offs. Every path has uncertainty. The question isn’t “Which decision will protect me from regret?” but rather, “Which decision feels most aligned with who I am becoming?”

When we shift the question, the pressure softens. It becomes less about avoiding mistakes and more about honoring authenticity.

Coming Back to Ourselves

So, how do we make decisions from a place of alignment? I often guide clients through three practices:

  1. Slow Down. When urgency drives us, we usually default to old patterns. Pausing allows space for reflection. Even saying, “I’ll decide tomorrow,” can shift the pressure.
  2. Listen to All Three Centers. What does the mind say? The heart? The gut? Write them out. Name the fears and the longings. This gives each part of you a voice.
  3. Ask the Authenticity Question. Instead of “What will please others?” or “What is safest?” ask: “Which choice brings me closer to my truest self?”

Authenticity doesn’t mean selfishness. It means choosing from the deep center of who you are, not from fear or conditioning. Ironically, when we do that, the people around us often benefit too.

When You Still Don’t Know

Sometimes, even after all this, clarity doesn’t come right away. That’s okay. Some decisions ripen slowly, like fruit on a tree. In those moments, your work is not to force clarity but to stay close to yourself.

Trust that when you are ready, when your mind has discerned, your heart has softened, and your gut has gathered courage, the way forward will show itself.

A Closing Word

If decision-making feels heavy for you right now, know this: there’s nothing “wrong” with you. You are not failing at life. You are simply being human in a complex world, carrying influences, wounds, and longings that all deserve compassion.

The real invitation is not to get every decision “right,” but to use decision-making as a path back to authenticity. Each choice is a chance to remember who you are, and to live from that place more fully.

And that, ultimately, is what heals. It is not the decisions themselves, but the way they lead us back to our home-ourselves.

WALLACE MURRAY

Psychotherapy | Coaching | Facilitation | Educator | Urban Shamanism | Psychedelic Assisted Therapy

Get Your Complimentary 30 Minute Phone Consultation